Let's compare...
Reason for win:
Isine has a total of 60% bonuses in critical areas (Offense, Defense, MDefense), while Thor has a total of 30% bonuses situated in only the two offenses (It is not efficient to split offenses)

Thor has stronger special attacks, but Isine has more special attacks, granting a better probability to use them. Better to use special attacks than basic

Isine wins
 


11/20/2011 17:45

Isine

Isidor
11/22/2011 12:38

isine

Mellissa
11/22/2011 14:16

I think Isine because my Thor gets beaten by Isine.Furthermore it has more bonuses and you can put a weakness imprint in it it has more bonuses than Thor.Isine has 4 bonuses but THOR has two bonuses and Isine also has wind and judgement as well as a basic 115 light attack as there are more dark guards as I have seen for example outcast,wicked,hellforse,werewolf,knight and some of the new guards.
My regards Mellisa
Sorry i wrote this long i mostly write really long its a habit.
:)

Kodeplay10
11/22/2011 17:18

@Mellissa Haha it's ok

虎丁
11/23/2011 08:52

PIkachu will win... jkjk ~~~ Isine

11/23/2011 10:49

a very even match up: Thor might have less defense but with hybrid Thor uses a t. hammer that does massive damage like super punch for rexa and they both have same speed so it comes down to pure luck on if thor decides to use his special moves or not.

isine- 55% chance of winning
thor- 45% chance of winning

k
11/23/2011 21:49

isine

Painful
04/22/2012 11:11

Isine

Im A Sucker
11/24/2011 21:01

I think isine because just by looking at him i can tell and plus you can check their stats and moves

Yu-sa
11/29/2011 22:21

Isine most definite

Dark Shadow--)=====>
12/03/2011 13:48

Iseni

Dark Money
12/04/2011 02:50

I believe isine will win it's wind type is unaffected by throes light and electric moves. Thor also cannot beat isine with atk cause sine have good def and mdef stats

shadowdemon9427
12/04/2011 11:32

its time i put this into perspective

#1: we must forget type advantage as all of thier attacks do even damage to ther other

#1: winner: tie

#2: the move sets: isine has a base 100 and a base 115 magical attack (the same as thor) and then 2 140 specials and 1 150 special while thor has 1 150 special and 1 170 special

#2:winner: tie

#3:defense of thor is much lower then isines but thors base attack is much higher to counter it

#3: winner: inconclusive (depends on attack)

#4: attack

thor has a much higher attack base then isine its 115 base stat of attack completly destroys isine who only has 65 base def while thors magical attack does mediocer damage since isine has a 90 base stat in mdef while thor only has about 60 base stat in magic attack

isine has only magical attacks and thor has a base 31 mdef stat which allows isine to destroy thor but only if it uses its special attacks

#4: winner: inconclusive (depends on defense)

#5: speed: they both have 28 speed so...

#5: winner: tie

#6: intellegence

the battle is decided upon who uses thier special attack and who goes first and isine has more inteelegence then thor

#6: winner: isine

conclusion: they both are very strong attackers but thor has more attack while isine has more defense so attack and defense ar inconclusive while the intellegence decides who uses there special move and isine has more intellegence but who are we to trust riidas math? and so the battle is decided on pure luck! who goes first and who uses thier special attacks decides the winner...

overall winning probability: isine has a 55% chance and thor has a 45% chance so its not dead even but the battle will likely end in a tie

if it was irina: thor would win since irina has an even lower defense

if they had imprints: thor would need an imprint of any stat while most people put weakness on isine (disregard assault imprint) so thor would win if he had an imprint

sorry this was so long but this is a very close battle and you must consider every possibility

fff
01/15/2012 14:17

probably a tie but if thor had a good imprint thor would most likely win

EXILED DEMON
01/17/2012 16:22

ah-ha! but if isine had an good imprint he/she would beat Thor that's why its so hard to decide

also note that they are both banned from palringo tournaments

RARR!
01/22/2012 14:54

Oh yeah... do guards have genders?

Kodeplay10
01/25/2012 20:17

It is debatable whether guards have genders. For example, if you look at DOGI, the white one is male, and the pink one is female.

EXILED DEMON
01/29/2012 21:06

that's not accurate, we have no physical proof of any genders of guards except for dragon queen who is female

Kodeplay10
01/29/2012 22:09

That's why I said it's debatable. I didn't say that there is 100% proof there are genders, did I?

EXILED DEMON
01/31/2012 19:38

i....actually didn't see the part where you said debatable untill now...whoops

Cutie Chue
01/24/2012 23:35

I think ISINE will win coz he's one of the best guards around and......he's better than THOR is better I send out one and fought this guy's Thor and my Ultimate(is my isine's name) fought that Thor and it use JUDGEMENT and it was like a quarter of my isine's health and my isine use JUDGEMENT and one shot KO!
Sorry I typed this long but I wanted to list down the facts.

EXILED DEMON
01/29/2012 21:09

this is really bad

#1: its base stats

#2: its base moves so no specials

#3: you were probably a higher level

#4: why did you delete my comment and not hers kodeplay?

Kodeplay10
01/29/2012 22:06

I did not like your attitude for the comment. You get easily annoyed by just simple blog posts and I have already warned you before.

EXILED DEMON
01/31/2012 19:34

sorry if I'm a bit bi-polar, ill try to be more controlled but when i have a bad day little things that mean nothing can set me off. often these chats become a rage outlet, they shouldn't, these people did nothing wrong, but i have a bunch of issues that slowly tear away at my sanity. sorry everyone, ill try not to blog when I'm feeling angry

Erika
01/30/2012 13:56

Well THOR vs ISINE.
THOR is a normal type which mean no weakness but ISINE has a weakness to dark and it takes double damage.
Isine has a variety of moves more than THOR.
Isine has loads of Int and bonus stats
Thor has a 170 Normal move
So overall i think Isine

EXILED DEMON
02/01/2012 15:43

everyones against me :(

also thats 3 pros for thor and 2 for isine so isnt that thor overall?

Jason
02/02/2012 04:16

isine

Levi
02/03/2012 08:41

Isine, his stat bonuses are killer.

EXILED DEMON
02/03/2012 15:15

No one even reads my evaluation, it makes me sad :(

I have a feeling people say isine just cuz it's the #1 guard but it's Thor vs. Isine not the guard overall, if it were overall then clearly isine is the winner, but it's vs.

Like a Boss
02/15/2012 15:57

Because people never train both atk and matk, thor's only bonus is atk. isine also has the same matk bonus but a 15% def bonus an 15% int bonus. at high levels, bonus is more important than base stats. I'm not saying he's not good, but what makes thor so good? is it T. Hammer?

EXILED DEMON
02/16/2012 14:42

its Thor VS. Isine and BASE STATS

FOR THE LAST TIME, LOOK AT THE EVALUATION I PUT UP!

WiiPlayer101
02/28/2012 02:02

We have our own opinions. Both are good, but like everyone says the imprint decides the battle, so basically I think they are even.

Like A Boss
03/27/2012 18:26

Where does it say its base stats?

20jiayiming
02/12/2012 22:58

ISINE!

friend
03/07/2012 08:10

definitly isne

EXILED DEMON
03/11/2012 10:05

i think people should explain why they think isine would win because they are clearly just picking isine because its better overall and not against thor

The Boyzz
03/22/2012 21:49

IsInE! Duh

EXILED DEMON
03/24/2012 17:59

:(

Edison123
03/26/2012 04:46

I think isine

EXILED DEMON
03/26/2012 15:30

:( :(

EXILED DEMON
03/28/2012 23:24

Why won't anyone read my evaluation!?
It's most likely a tie!

qwertyuiopasdfghjklxcvbnnm
03/28/2012 23:25

quertziop!( Isine)

Me
03/28/2012 23:29

Hmm... If Thor has 170 normal but Isine had 150 LIGHT, Isine had higher base stats,and the defense Isine has would block Thor , but Thor can use other types of moves so it would really base on what imprint they had, but if no imprint Isine would win! I hope that cleared some things up.

20jiayiming
03/28/2012 23:30

Yes it did Me. Besides who are you Me?

Me
03/28/2012 23:30

I'm Me.

20jiayiming
03/28/2012 23:31

Oh.

20jiayiming
03/28/2012 23:32

Now that I read "Me" and EXILED DEMON's evaluation I think it will end up as a tie.

EXILED DEMON
04/02/2012 18:06

yes! thank you, people only say isine cuz she/he is better in quests. thank you

:)
04/04/2012 21:59

pooey. this is tough.

20jiayiming
04/04/2012 22:00

haha. "pooey" LOL

sniffer
04/04/2012 22:00

Thor! Because his hammer is crazy!

Blackfang773
04/06/2012 04:01

First,add the stat total(imma not pick any cuz i dun like math)
Then,find the differences(and which will have exact,not estimated)
Best to list the values(Thor might have + in attack and value,blah)
After That,(If you noticed.i skipped the star things)if unlocked special skills, check on the chance of the skill striking.(with each skill)
Check the other's skill use percentage
(Ran out of words since i didnt sleep and its 2am here): If using imprints, check EVERY single combination,result after 10+ battles by percentage.
If you are actually going to try stat distribution, DON'T even ask me!
Note:Intelligence doesnt even do any crap on thor,no offence(heard from my clan leader that he gave thor 200 intelligence and he only uses lightning)
Body Types: Check highest and lowest damage possible with every combination of stats,imprints,etc against isine

Thepersonwhojustposted
04/06/2012 04:04

Forgot to add how many times it will attack with the chance and how many times it would win

04/11/2012 20:13

I Isine will probably win

Typhlosion
04/13/2012 18:42

Isine will certainly :3

Popcorn
04/17/2012 18:51

Isine would totally win!!!!!!

Reply to EXILED DEMON (I am Popcorn)
04/18/2012 00:01

There is no such thing as a tie, atleast in Pocket Summoner. If you gow a Rank 1 Isine and a Rank 1 Thor, than Thor might win, but if they were both higher in rank, than Isine would smash Thor with Judgement as long as it had good speed, magic attack and intelligence.

Popcorn
04/18/2012 00:03

Sorry, change that 'gow' into a 'get'.


Comments are closed.